Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery vs Columbia Periodontal Associates: which fits same-day implants better?

Updated 2026-07-21 · 326 reviewed · 38 listed · How we rank ›

Both practices are legitimate options in Columbia for same-day or immediate load implants, and both post strong review numbers, but the surgical infrastructure and same-day workflow differ in ways that matter for this specific job. This comparison uses our methodology to weigh those differences rather than just the headline scores.

Verdict

For same-day or immediate load implants specifically, Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery is the stronger fit. Its AAAHC-accredited surgical center, explicit handling of full arch restorations, and stated readiness to fit in urgent cases line up directly with what immediate load implant work demands. Columbia Periodontal Associates is a solid choice with excellent credentials and strong follow-up care, but its same-day availability reads as occasional rather than built-in, and the noted high fees are worth weighing if cost matters for an urgent case.

Side by side

Criterion	Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery	Columbia Periodontal Associates
Google rating	4.9 (1170 reviews)	4.9 (869 reviews)
Services	all on 4 full arch, single tooth implants, implant oral surgery, same day implants	all on 4 full arch, single tooth implants, implant oral surgery, same day implants
Verification	Google-verified	Google-verified
Composite score	93	91

Google rating: Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: 4.9 (1170 reviews); Columbia Periodontal Associates: 4.9 (869 reviews)
Services: Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: all on 4 full arch, single tooth implants, implant oral surgery, same day implants; Columbia Periodontal Associates: all on 4 full arch, single tooth implants, implant oral surgery, same day implants
Verification: Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: Google-verified; Columbia Periodontal Associates: Google-verified
Composite score: Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: 93; Columbia Periodontal Associates: 91

Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.

What reviewers say

Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery

Staff greet patients with genuine warmth and take time explaining each option without rushing. Dr. Van Hook and Dr. Pham earn consistent praise for their skill and kindness, supported by a team that calms nervous patients and answers questions thoroughly throughout the process.

The practice serves complex cases including wisdom tooth removal, emergency extractions, and full arch restorations. A clean facility, punctual scheduling, and willingness to fit in new patients for urgent care distinguish the center from competitors in the region.

Columbia Periodontal Associates

Staff and doctors earn consistent praise for gentleness and taking time to explain procedures clearly. Patients note that front desk, hygienists, and multiple named doctors (Park, McEntire, Hedgpath) go above and beyond with follow-up calls and genuine concern for comfort.

The practice handles extractions, gum grafts, periodontal cleaning, and implant work across three locations. One reviewer acknowledged high fees but felt the experience justified the price. Multiple visits from returning patients suggest strong retention.

Still not sure which fits?

Describe what you're looking for once and get replies from suitable dental implants provider in Columbia, SC.

Enquiries submitted through our contact forms may be passed to partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are not influenced by referral fees.