Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery vs Family Dental Health of Forest Acres: which fits All-on-4 & full arch implants?
Both practices score nearly identically overall, but All-on-4 and full arch work is oral surgery first and restorative dentistry second, which changes the calculus. Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery and Family Dental Health of Forest Acres are worth comparing directly because one is built around surgical complexity and the other around general dental care with strong chairside manner. See our methodology for how these scores are built.
Verdict
For All-on-4 and full arch implants specifically, fit points toward Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: it's a dedicated oral surgery practice with an accredited surgical center and named experience in full arch restorations, backed by a larger review base at the same 4.9 rating. Family Dental Health of Forest Acres is a strong pick if you need a general dentist for the surrounding care (cleanings, extractions, calming a nervous patient) but its summary doesn't point to the surgical depth this specific procedure requires.
Which should you pick?
Pick Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery if
- You need actual surgical placement of implants for an All-on-4 or full arch case
- You want a board-certified surgeon and an accredited surgical center for sedation or complex bone work
- You have a complicated case history (grafting, extractions, urgent surgical needs) alongside the implant plan
Pick Family Dental Health of Forest Acres if
- You want a general dentist to handle cleanings, exams, or prep work and can be referred out for the surgical portion
- You're anxious about dental visits generally and want a calm, fast-moving practice for everyday care
- You need a same-day appointment for a toothache or general issue rather than surgical implant placement
The differences that matter
- Surgical specialization. Carolinas Center is an oral and facial surgery practice with board-certified surgeons and an AAAHC-accredited surgical center built for complex cases like full arch restorations, while Family Dental Health is a general family dental office.
- Case complexity handled. Carolinas Center's stated case mix includes wisdom teeth, emergency extractions, and full arch restorations specifically, whereas Family Dental Health's summary centers on cleanings, extractions, and general surgery without naming full arch cases.
- Facility accreditation. Carolinas Center operates an AAAHC-accredited surgical center, a distinction relevant to sedation and multi-implant surgical placement that Family Dental Health's listing does not mention.
- Review volume and track record. Carolinas Center has nearly double the review base (1,170 vs 597) at the same 4.9 rating, giving it a larger sample size specifically as a surgical provider.
- Pace and setting. Family Dental Health emphasizes fast, in-and-out visits (often 45 minutes) suited to routine dental work, while Carolinas Center's model fits longer, more involved surgical appointments.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: 4.9 (1185 reviews)
- Family Dental Health of Forest Acres: 4.8 (605 reviews)
- Services
- Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: all on 4 full arch, implant oral surgery, single tooth implants, implant periodontics
- Family Dental Health of Forest Acres: all on 4 full arch, single tooth implants, same day implants, sedation implant dentistry
- Full arch / All-on-4 fit
- Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: Purpose-built: surgical center plus named experience with full arch restorations
- Family Dental Health of Forest Acres: Not specifically named in case mix; oriented toward general and restorative dentistry
- Best for
- Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: Patients needing surgical placement of multiple implants, bone grafting, or sedation for complex cases
- Family Dental Health of Forest Acres: Patients wanting a trusted general dentist for prep work, cleanings, or straightforward extractions before referral to a surgeon
- Team
- Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: Dr. Van Hook and Dr. Pham, both surgeons
- Family Dental Health of Forest Acres: Dr. Hicklin and hygienist team, general dentistry focus
- Verification
- Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: Google-verified
- Family Dental Health of Forest Acres: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery: 93
- Family Dental Health of Forest Acres: 87
What reviewers say
Carolinas Center for Oral & Facial Surgery
Reviewers consistently report feeling heard and informed. Dr. Pham and Dr. Van Hook explain diagnoses and options without rushing, and staff members are described as warm, attentive, and genuinely invested in patient comfort. The center maintains high standards of cleanliness and professionalism across all interactions, from front desk to surgical care.
Wisdom tooth extraction and oral surgery are the most frequently praised services. Patients with accessibility needs or hearing challenges note they were never made to feel rushed or belittled. Follow-up care is thorough, and the surgical facility operates with AAAHC accreditation standards.
Family Dental Health of Forest Acres
Most patients praise the warm, unhurried atmosphere and dental skill here, naming Dr. Pincelli and Dr. Hicklin specifically. One patient had a difficult crown experience where healthy teeth were adjusted twice before the crown itself, leading to ongoing bite and jaw pain that required a second opinion to resolve.
The office serves veterans well and maintains a reputation for gentle care and professionalism. Review evidence for the specific implant categories is limited, though one extraction and oral surgery visit was noted positively.
Still not sure which fits?
Describe what you're looking for once and get replies from suitable dental implants provider in Columbia, SC.
Your enquiries may be shared with partner providers who can do the work, and we may earn a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based on our published method only and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Does Family Dental Health of Forest Acres perform All-on-4 surgery itself?
- The data doesn't list full arch restorations in its case mix; its strengths are cleanings, general extractions, and same-day emergency dental care.
- Why does surgical accreditation matter for full arch implants?
- All-on-4 involves placing multiple implants often under sedation, so an AAAHC-accredited surgical center, which Carolinas Center has, is built specifically for that level of complexity.
- Which practice has more review volume?
- Carolinas Center has 1,170 reviews versus 597 for Family Dental Health, both at a 4.9 rating.